As we continue our walk down memory lane in this 90th anniversary year, we come to one of the most defining chapters in the history of St. Matthew Lutheran Church—a story marked by bold vision, deep trial, and unwavering faith.
On November 24, 1963, the congregation took a courageous step forward by partnering with the American Church Finance Company to launch a comprehensive building, financing, and stewardship program. The goal was ambitious: $500,000 to build a new church, school, and fellowship hall on 5.2 acres at Venoy and Beechwood. Over an acre of this land was generously donated by Dr. W. H. Kern and his wife, Iola, a gift that helped make the vision possible.
In December of that same year, the congregation purchased a home on Warren Avenue to serve as the new parsonage for Pastor Friedrich and his family, preparing for the next phase of ministry.
By April 1, 1964, bond subscriptions began—and in a remarkable act of faith and generosity, the full amount was raised even before construction started. Since not all funds were immediately needed, the congregation agreed to loan $205,000 to a non-profit nursing home in Ohio, with repayment expected within six months.
Ministry continued to grow during this time. In the fall of 1964, Rev. Herbert Daenzer began assisting Pastor Friedrich with preaching.
Then came a day the congregation would never forget.
On May 16, 1965, members gathered one final time at 5900 Middlebelt Road. Following a valedictory devotion, the Elders carried the sacred items from the old church as the congregation processed to their new home at 5885 Venoy Road. There, they entered together for a Service of Dedication, celebrating with worship, meals, and fellowship. The school was dedicated the following week on May 23, completing the new campus.
But soon after, an unexpected challenge arose.
As the final contractor payment came due, the congregation learned that $111,000 of the loaned funds had not been returned. Further investigation revealed that a large portion of the money had been misused, leaving the loss without recourse.
Though shocking and disheartening, the congregation responded with faith—not fear. As Pastor Friedrich shared, “nobody panicked… what this did was solidify the people.” Members sacrificially gave, raising $50,000 toward the loss, with some even donating their bonds back to the building fund.
Through God’s guidance and faithful leadership, what could have divided the congregation instead unified and strengthened it. The mission continued, grounded not in circumstances, but in Christ.
In time, the Middlebelt property was sold and eventually became the site of today’s Kroger Shopping Center—a reminder of where St. Matthew once stood and how faithfully God has led His people forward.
This chapter reminds us:
The Church is not built on buildings, but on faith—and God’s faithfulness never fails.
